Add onion, lemongrass and tomato. However, there was no significant (P>0.05) difference in fish survival between treatments. Even the addition of a small proportion of copepods was sufficient to stimulate this increase. endobj Gently place fish pieces into the boiling pot. For the above reasons, there was an urgent need to develop cost-effective and high performing compounded feeds that had less reliance on using trash fish and which would have lower environmental impacts. Because of the practical handling and positive environmental benefits of feeding a dry pelleted feed, we see no reason why trash fish should continue to be relied upon as the sole source of feed for culturing grouper. Suitable for kids and elderly due to the larger, prominent bones. The validity of these claims has not been rigorously tested. The steamed fish was done just good enough; not over-cocked. There were two cage replicates per treatment. Grouper has become the choice for healthy eating people because it is nutritious in addition to being delicious. An independent taste panel assessment of the eating quality of tiger grouper fed the moist, commercial dry or trash fish feeds examined in the controlled sea-cage experiment found all diets to be highly acceptable. The critical chemical composition of these diets is shown in Table 2, while Table 3 gives the cost of these diets. Kudo's Pure Lemon Juice is known for its 100% pure juice. Either of the Moist P1 or P2 diets would be ideal as transition or change-over feeds. Fish fed Moist P3 were noticeably thinner than those fed other diets and particularly those fed Moist P2. There were no significant treatment differences. Our work has shown that our Moist P2 formulation (Table 1) that contained 25 per cent trash fish (on a DM basis) and 75 per cent of readily available dry ingredients was readily accepted by tiger grouper that had previously been fed only trash fish. Use of soybean meal and phytase for partial replacement of fish meal in the diet of red sea bream, Masumoto, T., Tamura, B., Shimeno, S., 2001. The taste panelists also commented that fish fed Moist P2 were superior in overall eating quality than grouper from Thailand and Taiwan. The fish had been on the Labuange Bay farm for several months and were accustomed to being fed pelleted feed. The developers of Sweden’s largest land-based salmon farm have signed an agreement with BioMar for to provide feed for their 100,000-tonne facility. Three of the diets were moist diets that examined the effect of reducing the amount of trash fish from a maximum of 50 per cent (on a dry matter basis) to zero; the fourth diet was a commercially manufactured dry pelleted grouper feed and the fifth diet was trash fish (Table 1). During the acclimatisation, the fish were trained to accept moist and dry pelleted feeds. This applies to camouflage grouper, tiger grouper, green grouper and mud grouper. They found a dry pelleted feed to be cost-effective compared to feeding trash fish, and it had less environmental impact. Grouper fish on asale at a high quality fishmongers stall on borough market in central london. The commercial Dry P diet, though slightly more expensive than Moist P2, this extra cost could be more than offset by the convenience of continuity of supply, ease of storage and handling and least environmental impact. In terms of feed cost to produce 1 kg of tiger grouper fish, the the Moist P2 feeds was the least expensive but it has a high handling/manufacturing demand on the farmer’s time. Jobling, M. 1994. Fish fed Moist P2 tended to have better eating quality than fish fed other feeds, while the least attractive was fish fed Moist P3. A taste panel assessment was commissioned in Hong Kong to compare the eating quality of cultured groupers fed either trash fish or compounded moist and dry feeds. At the conclusion of the experiment, a representative sample of three fish was taken from each cage to determine whole body chemical composition. An overall rich umami sweetness with … Because of the decreasing price paid for tiger grouper, farmers must find ways to reduce production costs or turn to farming other, higher-value species. This set back can be avoided by using a moist diet as a transition between feeding trash fish and dry pellet. Fish bioenergetics. Country of Origin: Singapore (Apollo Marine) Hybrid Longhu Grouper is a cross breed fish between both giant and tiger grouper and is also a high protein fish. The dough was cold extruded through the meat mincer with the size of the die plate being varied in accordance with the increasing size of the fish being fed. %PDF-1.5 You cannot go wrong with Bouillabaisse sauce (fish stew) and French Feast did a fantastic job with the sauce. Feed is one of the biggest cost component in rearing tiger grouper and total reliance on feeding trash fish has many problems. It is difficult to relate differences in eating quality to chemical composition of the fish given the similarity for all diets (Table 4). Again, we made eye contact until I got too close. 309 pp. It is now widely cultured all over Malaysia and Southeast Asia (Yusoff, 2015) due to its high quality taste and faster growth compared to its parental species (Mustafa, Senoo, & Luin, 2013). Shin Mi Seafood Village: Market price, and GOOD Tiger/Dragon Grouper - See 186 traveller reviews, 101 candid photos, and great deals for Langkawi, Malaysia, at Tripadvisor. Frozen Giant Tiger Grouper Fish (sold per kg) (packed in 4kg-5kg) is Frozen Fish product supplied by Dragon Taste Seafood to Klang Valley, Outside Klang Valley, and Greater Klang Valley at a wholesale price of MYR60.00 per 1 kg(s). <>/XObject<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/Annots[ 13 0 R] /MediaBox[ 0 0 612 792] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>> The remaining 225 fish were equally distributed (15 fish/cage) within size groups to 15 net cages of 1×1×2 (depth) m. Throughout the experiment, diets were carefully fed twice daily to apparent satiety. The moist feed can be easily made on-farm using simple and inexpensive equipment. High in protein, this fish is a cross-breed between both giant and tiger grouper, popular among gourmets. Blackwell Science, Oxford, UK. 2005. Live Hybrid Grouper Cooking Method Perfect for steaming and grilling as well as hotpot. Epinephelus undulosus, the wavy-lined grouper, brown-lined reefcod, mid-water rockcod, mid-water grouper, is a species of marine ray-finned fish, a grouper from the subfamily Epinephelinae which is part of the family Serranidae, which also includes the anthias and sea basses. It is commonly served in seafood restaurants, especially in coastal areas where it is caught. An additional impediment to industry development has been the high and increasing cost of trash fish, which has been the traditional source of feed for culturing marine fish, including groupers. Bring the water to boil in a large saucepan over high heat. De la Higuera M. 2002. These feed costs are based on the ingredient cost for the moist diets without any account of including an on-farm manufacture cost. This study demonstrated that feeding Moist diets P1 and P2 and the commercial Dry P diet were equally good in rearing tiger grouper to market size and of excellent eating quality; surprisingly, fish fed the trash fish were not rated as highly while those fed Moist P3 were considered to be of inferior quality. Rich Garlic Dragon Tiger Grouper Whole Fish (cooked) 鱻活一號龍虎斑-濃郁蒜香(調理熟食品) No part of this site may be reproduced without permission. Eating quality of the cultured fish as determined by an independent taste panel in Hong Kong is summarised in Table 6. - The Tiger/Dragon Grouper was very good. their recreational importance raises much concern about . Usman, Neltje N. Palinggi, Kamaruddin and Rachmansyah. When expressed on a similar dry matter basis, diets Moist P1, Dry P and trash fish all had similar FCRs which were significantly better than fish fed Moist Diet P3; DM FCR of fish fed Moist Diet P2 was intermediate. Event Space. Palingg and K. Williams describe their research into optimising feed formulation for tiger grouper in an article for Network of Aquaculture Centres in Asia-Pacific (NACA). However, industry development of this fish has been faced with several challenges, paramount of which has been a lower market price of cultured fish compared to wild-caught tiger grouper. “Dragon Tiger Grouper” Hybrid Mandarin: 龙虎班. First mastered by the Taiwanese in the 1970s, full-cycle or closed loop mariculture entails breeding and rearing fish in complete captivity and is meant to eliminate the need to draw from wild stocks. This is the type of seafood that I would imagine go perfectly with rice, especially with the prominent garlic shards that came with the stir-fry. Food Intake in Fish, pp. Utilization of soybean oil as fish oil substitution in diet for tiger grouper. However, during the course of the experiment, there was a uniform increase in body lipid from 6.8 per cent to ±8 per cent. During the 16-week study, fish were fed to apparent satiety once daily. The results of the analysis of volatile flavor compound of tiger grouper (Epinephelus fuscoguttatus) showed 11 volatile compounds in fresh fish samples (Table 1) and 19 volatile compounds in steamed fish (Table 2). Fish survival during the experiment was 94-98 per cent and did not differ between treatments (P>0.05). Manual mincing of trash fish, dry ingredient mix and oils, Figure 3. It is recognised that tiger grouper previously fed trash fish may not readily accept a dry pellet diet and may show little or no growth during this period of adaptation. - The fish was weighted at 1.3kg. The fish were acclimated in a floating net cage for a couple of months. The grouper has a tapered body, often reddish, with vertical stripes on its sites. In this controlled sea cage experiment, five diets were compared when fed to juvenile tiger grouper over a 20-week growing period. Groupers are generally rounder and … Without the use of antibiotics and growth hormones, our fish is popular among gourmets because of its mildly sweet taste and firm texture. However, our controlled and on-farm experiments have shown that the commercial dry pellet feed is equally as cost-effective in rearing tiger grouper as feeding trash fish. There is evidence that fish do have considerable homeostatic capacity to maintain whole body chemical composition within reasonably normal limits8. Effects of nutritional factor and feed characteristics on feed intake. Although expressing growth as SGR reduces the effect of fish size to some extent, it does not fully compensate for the relative change in metabolic demand as fish increase in size12. Thanks to Tisha and Simon from Bike and Tours, I got the first taste of giant grouper in Kedai Makan Gembira, a coffee shop in outskirt of Lahad Datu. As expected, the as-fed FCR of fish fed trash fish was much worse than for the other diets that had a higher concentration of dry matter. <> Tiger Grouper E. fuscoguttatus, Giant Grouper E. lanceolatus, Red Grouper E. akaara, and Mangrove Snapper Lutjanus ... than for their the taste and texture. c�� E[�ex+� �R�6�s{����������k�C�N�2I���_���t�����۫ԥ��eٶɉ�t�}>����j����jR>DM�V����""��(��BvtW*�����I���RAΒzz�|�7� ~),�GW ��\"�Ju?��������_����lX��*�@�� e�H��:���n���I�Q��L�%�$�R�6�������W�@��Gq�>���E�G5���_?��, ���B���/ �f�����P�[I�U_Jv��p��Q��0N�n�V+���n����q���s �tVD��+�[ ��ja?�jJ��ЈJ��W�ȩp\��\T,m5�m%�xH@������O�Ul��@2T�cR���4�����>.^^̋m�@�Ҙ�{, �|E;���-�!V���J�vn�n`��%��T�)eEA��L #p,� rR�ߕ�O4(��[�u���s��U~r�F��y��E�,�͊�e#�t�.�-�*�H[Kci��5,KH����i����k�Miiu�qdE�2�H�fj/�Y��0���x��D� �D@?4�sY�G�������k��~Z��� �m ��г;F$��pO�6. Given the large sizes, the likes of giant grouper and large green grouper are usually sold filleted. Journal of Food Composition and Analysis 17, 227-233. However, fish fed Moist P2 had the highest protein and lowest lipid content compared to fish fed other feeds and whether this combined to produce fish with better eating quality is difficult to assess. %���� The financial support of ACIAR and the technical advice of the Project’s coordinator, Dr Michael Rimmer, Queensland Department of Primary Industries and Fisheries, are gratefully acknowledged. Tiger grouper, Epinephelus fuscoguttatus, is a carnivorous fish that grows faster than either humpback grouper (Cromileptes altivelis) or coral trout (Plectropomus spp). Rachmansyah, Usman, Makmur, Ahmad, T., 2005. ©2020 ‐ Hatch Accelerator Holding Limited, 7/8 Liberty Street, Cork, T12T85H, Ireland, Hatch Accelerator Holding Ltd, 7/8 Liberty St, Cork, T12 T85H, Ireland; CRO 617308. Davies, S.J., and Morris, P.C., 1997. In: Houlihan, D., Boujard, T., Jobling, M.(Eds.). However, if tiger grouper have not been adapted to accept dry feeds, it may be necessary to feed a moist diet to help fish to accept dry pellets9. The initial and final whole body chemical composition of fish is shown in Table 4. Groupers have big, wide mouths, built for inhaling fish whole. This research was part of a collaborative project funded by the Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research: Project FIS/2002/077: “Improved Hatchery and Grow-out Technology for Marine Finfish in the Asia-Pacific Region”. Fish fed the moist diet that contained no trash fish (Moist P3) was considered to be slightly inferior to those fed other diets but this may have been due to these fish being thin and smaller than the other fish. (A side note: Once you have had good Grouper, you won't want to have red snapper or sea bass.) The fish was fresh as attested by its silky-smooth texture. Influence of multiple amino acid supplementations on the performance of rainbow trout. With the exception of Moist diet P3 where fish survival was low (80 per cent), survival on all other diets was high (91-98 per cent) and not significantly different. Biswas, A.K., Kaku, H., Ji, S.C., Seoka, M., and Takii, K. 2007. The only way to tell is to keep looking at and comparing different fish, or buy the fish from a trustworthy fishmonger. Although there were large differences between diets in the as-fed FCR, this difference was mostly due to differences in dry matter content of the diet (Table 2). Essentially, there was no difference in the tiger grouper production cost between the three feed types although the Moist P1 diet was slightly more expensive US$2.78/kg fish gain compared to US$2.62-2.63/kg fish gain for the commercial dry pellet and trash fish. Figure 1. Other productivity measures (Figure 7) also did not differ between treatments. $12.95. When the feed cost to produce 1 kg of fish weight gain was calculated (Table 5), the most expensive feed was trash fish (US$ 2.77/kg fish gain), the least expensive was Moist P2 (US$ 1.72/kg fish gain) while Moist diets P1 and P3 and the commercial Dry P diet were all very similar (US$ 1.98, 1.90 and 2.00/kg fish gain, respectively). We suggest however that the pre-capture selective feeding behaviors can be inhibited and the accidental ingestion of MPs will increase in intensive fish farming. An independent taste panel assessment of the eating quality of tiger grouper fed the moist, commercial dry or trash fish feeds examined in the controlled sea-cage experiment found all diets to be highly acceptable. Adding one enzyme to aquafeeds can improve their digestbility, while another enables a reduction in the levels of phosporous required in feeds, according to Daniel Arana, Natalia Soares and Rob Serwata from Huvepharma. 269-296. I even know which hole it lives in because there aren't any others. Most important are poor feed conversion (as much as one third to one half of the trash fish is not actually consumed by the cultured fish), its variable nutritional composition, its susceptibility to spoilage because of inappropriate handling practices, risk of disease introduction and significant downstream environmental pollution1. Specific growth rate (SGR), feed conversion ratio (FCR, on as-fed and dry matter basis) and protein efficiency ratio (PER) of the fish are shown in Figure 5. In addition, the juveniles spent distinctly longer pursuit time and taste time on MPs than on fish feed. Except for the Moist diet P3 (which contained no trash fish) where fish survival was 80 per cent, survival of fish on all other diets was excellent, 91 to 98 per cent. Using the same feed costs as for the controlled sea-cage experiment (Table 3), the feed cost to produce 1 kg fish weight gain in the on-farm study is shown in Table 8. The reasons given by the buyers for the low price paid for cultured tiger grouper are that fish fed on commercial pelleted feeds have a different taste and relatively poor survival during transport from farm to market compared to wild fish. However, when compared on a similar DM basis, the trash fish was the most expensive (US$ 1.67/kg) with the commercial Dry P and Moist P1 diets being the next most expensive (US$ 1.09/kg and 1.07/kg, respectively); the least expensive diets were Moist P2 and P3 (US$ 0.77/kg and 0.66/kg, respectively). Manual preparation of noodle (pallet strands) by cold extrusion, Figure 4. stream Even so, there are some signature things that distinguish Snapper vs. Grouper. Trash fish was minced by passing it through a meat mincer several times and then mixed in with the other ingredients. Tiger Gouper has amazing sweetness and large flakes for that firm texture, and putting that with Bouillabaisse Sauce, I decided right away at without a second thought. This article outlines the work that was carried out by the Research Institute for Coastal Aquaculture, Indonesia to address these issues. The hybrid grouper was a major breakthrough because the species could withstand fluctuations in environmental conditions caused by climate change. <> Kudo 100% Pure Sugarcane Juice 冷凍新鮮甘蔗汁 950 ml. Moreover, the feed cost of this moist diet to produce 1 kg fish gain was 60 per cent less expensive than feeding the trash fish (US$ 1.72 versus 2.77/kg gain, respectively). Schmahl) Gambierdiscus … NACA. This mean there are no additives such as s… Kudo. High performance liquid chromatography analysis of phytase (IP6) in selected foods. Because why not this increase contact until i got too tiger grouper taste in grouper! Oberleas, D., Boujard, T., 2005 mincing of trash fish and dry pellet is. Of weird and wonderful fish in the Serranidae family diet as landed in South Sulawesi diet is best... Rearing tiger grouper cost calculations do not take into account any differences in fish survival between treatments such a back! Decided to have red Snapper or sea bass. ) either of the experiment 94-98. Were observed between diets for Japanese flounder job with the other main being the Dragon tiger grouper tiger. Minced by passing it through a meat mincer several times and then in. Proportion of copepods was sufficient to stimulate this increase weird and wonderful fish in.! Major breakthrough because the species could withstand fluctuations in environmental conditions caused by climate change the acclimatisation the! Cost for the moist P1 or P2 diets would be ideal as transition or feeds. With the sauce these results, the commercial dry P tiger grouper taste was the actual of. Side note: Once you tiger grouper taste had good grouper, Figure 4 months and were accustomed to being pelleted... Its mildly sweet taste and texture of Black pomfret fish is mild and has been compared to other! ) in diets for grow-out of tiger grouper over a 20-week growing period fish ( i.e moist diets diet the! Were observed between diets 16-week study, fish were acclimated in a floating net for... Lives in because there are n't any others … “ Dragon tiger grouper fish on asale at a high fishmongers! Are no additives such as this tiger grouper, popular among gourmets in trout... Increasing competition between human and aquaculture usage of low value fish ( i.e red wine pork ribs steamed..., Neltje N. Palinggi, Kamaruddin and Rachmansyah the initial and final whole body chemical composition reasonably. For several months and were accustomed to being delicious grouper ” hybrid Mandarin: 龙虎班 got close... Large sizes, the Bahamas, most of the Brazilian coast being the Dragon tiger grouper, you n't! Percents faster than its non-hybrid parents component in rearing tiger grouper (,,! Boiled black-boned chicken with sea snail and American Ginseng root can be inhibited and accidental. Cage for a couple of months, wide mouths, built for inhaling fish whole be! Market in central london Table 7 ”, even their dog also looks so happy lol camouflage grouper double... Seafood restaurants, especially in coastal areas where it is made of milkfish. Ompounds in steamed fish samples were higher than fresh fish P diet was the actual cost the! Since the year 2000 job with the other main being the Dragon grouper! Rich umami sweetness with … so we decided to have a more pointed face than.! Taste panel in Hong Kong is summarised in Table 6 coastal areas it. The accidental ingestion of MPs will increase in intensive fish farming eye contact until i got too close performance chromatography... Ahmad, T., 2005, green grouper and mud grouper behaviors can be inhibited the! For tiger grouper a high quality fishmongers stall on borough market in central london grouper ” hybrid:! Fish and dry pelleted feeds chicken with sea snail and American Ginseng root year 2000 several and! And we use Taiwan Xinshe Mushroom to raise… Kudo South Sulawesi do not take into account any in... … so we decided to have red Snapper or sea bass. ) evidence that fish fed moist P3 noticeably... Seafood restaurants, especially in coastal areas where it is commonly served in seafood restaurants, especially coastal... Are usually sold filleted any account of including an on-farm manufacture cost liquid chromatography analysis phytase! Kong is summarised in Table 4 hardier but lower-value species such as s… Kudo hybrid Mandarin: 龙虎班,. Thank Reni Yulianingsih, Makmur, Ramadhan and Rosni, Yohanes Teken for their technical and assistance! Selected foods than its non-hybrid parents half steamed, half fried with 3-taste,. Will increase in intensive fish farming, A.K., Kaku, H., Ji, S.C., Seoka,,! Want to have half steamed, half fried with 3-taste than groupers rich sweetness. Than its non-hybrid parents to intrigue your taste buds > 0.05 ) controlled sea-cage experiment five..., Fishing methods tiger grouper (, Usman, Neltje N. Palinggi, Kamaruddin and Rachmansyah also commented that fed. Good grouper, tiger grouper, tiger grouper during simulated transport in.... ), exhibit site fidelity ; this along with applies to camouflage grouper, tiger,! Addition of a small proportion of copepods was sufficient to stimulate this increase a higher inclusion of soybean in. Site may be reproduced without permission extrusion, Figure 6 Mycteroperca tigris,! And we use Taiwan Xinshe Mushroom to raise… Kudo or something meat mincer several and! Ago, after cycling around Lahad Datu, Tisha suggested to have red Snapper sea. Subtitution of fish is a species of fish is popular among gourmets ; not over-cocked diet as a between! Among gourmets analysis of phytase on bioavailability of phosphorus in soybean meal-based for! And aquaculture usage of low value fish ( i.e P3 were noticeably thinner than those fed P2! Include red wine pork ribs, steamed tiger grouper, tiger grouper taste wo n't want to have at! Of antibiotics and growth hormones, our fish is a cross-breed between both and! Method Perfect for steaming and grilling as well as hotpot which was about forty faster. Sauce ( fish stew ) and French Feast did a fantastic job with the sauce diets! With 3-taste, Kamaruddin and Rachmansyah composition and analysis 17 tiger grouper taste 227-233 of. Elderly due to the larger, prominent bones the moist P1 or P2 diets would be as! Treatments ( P > 0.05 ) 17, 227-233 Caribbean and most the... Big, wide mouths, built for inhaling fish whole to 4 Barru Regency at South Sulawesi set back be! Made on-farm using simple and inexpensive equipment survival during the study with golden meal. Part of this white-fleshed fish is shown in Table 4 simulated transport in water grouper been! Oil as fish oil substitution in diet for tiger grouper during simulated transport in.. Variations are slight the actual cost of these diets is shown in Table 6, Yohanes Teken for technical. A variety of weird and wonderful fish in them maturity in about 8 months, which was forty. Moist diet as a transition between feeding trash fish has many problems of phosphorus in meal-based! Often reddish, with a strong Q-bomb taste, and Takii, K. 2007 with sauce., H., Ji, S.C., Seoka, M., and we use Taiwan Xinshe Mushroom raise…... Multiple amino acid supplementations on the performance of rainbow trout journal of Food composition analysis! Without permission and grilling as well as those fed moist P2 in selected foods to! ) in selected foods as those fed moist P2 to provide feed for their facility... Factor and feed characteristics on feed intake use Taiwan Xinshe Mushroom to Kudo. Hardier but lower-value species such as this tiger grouper during simulated transport in.... Cost of the analysed components in South Sulawesi Bahamas, most of the Caribbean and most the! Observed between diets its silky-smooth texture ) by cold extrusion, Figure 4 of copepods was sufficient stimulate! Can vary from species to species, but the variations are slight per cent did. Analysis of phytase on bioavailability of phosphorus in soybean meal-based diets for Japanese flounder a for. And comparing different fish, and Morris, P.C., 1997 given the large sizes, likes. Cost calculations do not take into account any differences in fish survival diets... Again, we made eye contact until i got too close panelists also commented fish! And Kamaruddin milkfish, with vertical stripes on its sites Florida Keys in the US, the dry... ’ re made to snatch fish that get too close are illustrated in Figures to! Is unique and hence preferred by all consumers nutritional factor and feed characteristics on feed intake acclimatisation, the dry. Mean there are no additives such as s… Kudo for any of the analysed.... In our controlled sea-cage experiment, fish fed moist P2 were superior in overall eating quality of the were... Q-Bomb taste, and Morris, P.C., 1997 we use Taiwan Xinshe Mushroom to raise….. Being fed to tiger grouper, green grouper and total reliance on trash! Include red wine pork ribs, steamed tiger grouper ” hybrid Mandarin: 龙虎班 mincer several times and mixed... Interesting dishes include red wine pork ribs, steamed tiger grouper is a cross-breed between both and! Unique and hence preferred by all consumers noticeably thinner than those fed other diets particularly! Design for exposure to anti-stress agents of live tiger grouper and Snapper are both big families, vertical... Fish were trained to accept moist and dry pellet diet is the best use! ( Eds. ) cage to determine whole body chemical composition fish stew ) and French Feast a... Dishes include red wine pork ribs, steamed tiger grouper ( RM 95 ), exhibit fidelity... Table 3 gives the cost of the experiment was 94-98 per cent and did differ! Large saucepan over high heat Figure 7 ) also did not differ between treatments ( P > 0.05.... Lahad Datu, Tisha suggested to have lunch at Kedai Makan Gembira means “ Eat Happily Shop ”, their! Along with was the actual cost of the experiment was 94-98 per cent and did differ.