We shall learn about both of them in details and that will be followed by a Fluval Stratum vs Eco Complete comparison. I have a bunch of CaribSea Eco-Complete Planted Aquarium Substrate gravel left over from my live plant aquarium. I actually just removed all the Eco in my other tank and replaced with sand as well. Meaning if the powder is finer than the eco complet rocks it will eventually end up as your base layer. $29.82. best. Can't tell you whether or not it's worth it to change, but I loved it. Trending at $168.99. Didn't dose anything, no root tabs, nothing. 3,403 global ratings. I picked up a bag of eco complete off amazon but now I’m having cold feet about using it as my substrate. r/Aquariums: The subreddit for anything related to aquariums! If so, should I go with the Eco-Complete or Floramax? Caribsea Eco Complete; Search. your own Pins on Pinterest It was nearly impossible to plant my monte carlo, and to top it off even after thorough washing when I started adding water it left a coat of clay dust on all my hardscape, even after three water changes. no comments yet. What is amazing is that the substrate contains no coating, chemical, or any dye, and is completely natural. Sounds interesting, I’ve also looked into planted sands such as CaribSea Flora Max, which still seems to be quite difficult to find information on. I read that this substrate does not alter the ph or the gh, but, unfortunately, for some reason, the ph in my tank has gone through the roof. Floraspore symbionts activate the root-substrate interface to facilitate the uptake of minerals which make for a healthier root and healthier plant. Press J to jump to the feed. If you want to switch substrate, I'd pick something more different to make it worth it. The substrate has given me nothing but problems with it being so sharp and coarse, and the color is less than desirable. Cancel Unsubscribe. Thread starter NewAtFishKeeping; Start date Jan 19, 2020; Prev. Special order item. I made a major overhaul in my tank where I changed pretty much the way everything was arranged originally. I will be doing regular dosing of ferts as well as running CO2, I think the ADA will help significantly with my carpet. Keep the root tabs for heavy root feeders if you really need them, but I think the soil will keep you covered. CaribSea Life Rock $16/kg. I haven't noticed a difference between them for plant growth, but both my tanks are very low-tech. Link to Product and current Price. Advanced search. I would prefer substrates that are more soil like, but those seem to be the most expensive for what I’m doing. CaribSea Eco-Complete Black | 2020 Mix. 5.0 out of 5 stars 8. I think you'd be fine with using the ADA on it's self, honestly. We're also here to help you if you need advice. The soil should have enough nutrients for a while. CaribSea Aquatics Eco-Complete African Cichlid Zack Sand, 20-Pound, Black 4.3 out of 5 stars 123. However the gh is the same, about 4. CaribSea Eco-Complete or Floramax Black. I am in the midst of setting up a high tech planted, and having buyers remorse. Only 6 left in stock - order soon. See All Buying Options. Eco‑Complete’s™ secret lies in rich basaltic volcanic soil which contains iron, calcium, magnesium, potassium, sulfur plus over 25 other elements to nourish your aquatic plants. 5 star 81% 4 star 11% 3 star 4% 2 star 1% 1 star 3% CaribSea Eco-Complete 20-Pound Planted Aquarium, Black. The finest particle will always settle to the bottom of your tank. Could I use this as a good replacement for shells and dolomite? Each 20 pound box comes with a selection of arches, rings, tunnels and more! I've found it in Brown and black so you can have a different color if you don't like the black. CaribSea Eco-Complete Black Cichlid 20lb / 9.1kg. Sale. I think it’s beautiful and would buy again. Check Price. CaribSea Eco-Complete African Cichlid Sand Review Jake's Cichlids. I’ve looked into aqua soils and sands, but most are way too expensive compared to the amount you get. hide. I'm pretty lazy. Hello, I have had a 29 planted for over a year with Flourite and been very happy with the results and am now setting up a 60 gallon planted. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Subscribe Subscribed Unsubscribe 100. It was too expensive where I'm at. I initially tried doing a base of eco complete with mesh on top of it and then sand on top of that (to make sure the sand stays on top), but didn't have a lot of success with it. See All - Best Selling. Our reasoning behind this was: It is excellent value for money. save. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. You could always use the ADA now if you truly believe in it and then save the eco complete for a future set up. Messages 6,410 Reaction score 6,824 Location Long Island Experience More than 10 years It does seem like it’s a 50-50 chance your eco will be good. The addition of trace elements and PH buffering minerals can greatly increase the chances of your success in keeping these kinds of tanks. I picked up a bag of eco complete off amazon but now I’m having cold feet about using it as my substrate. CaribSea Aquatics Eco-Complete African Cichlid Zack Sand, 20-Pound, Black 4.5 out of 5 stars 202. Floraspore™ symbionts activate the root-substrate interface to facilitate the uptake of minerals which make for a healthier root and healthier plant. They hold plants down identically (i.e. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. 0 comments. Stock level: 19. I have never tried flourite. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Stock level: 66 . Sand was so much easier. A place for aquatic flora and fauna enthusiasts! share. Loading... Unsubscribe from Jake's Cichlids? 1; 2; First Prev 2 of 2 Go to page. The subreddit for anything related to aquariums! 1,141 Reviews. Carib Sea ACS00220 African Cichlid Mix for Aquarium, 20-Pound 4.5 out of 5 stars 22. $55.00. I hated using eco because it was incredibly frustrating to get any stem plants to stay in the substrate. I didn’t have any issues insta-cycling it with the HOB I moved over from the old tank either which was a bonus although I didn’t risk putting my two fish in there just in case. I like deep soil beds so I would put the eco complete at the back and use the ada to top it all off. Eco-Complete is a substrate that has maintained its position at the top of our list. CaribSea eco-complete Planted Substrate Black tank is the way to go. I like Eco complete, personally. I've heard only good things from people that use it. This is part one of two. I’m trying to find something that was relatively cheap, and after finding some reviews it is basically black Flourite that doesn’t cloud, which is fine but now what I’m looking for. Be the first to share what you think! I think I had 6 bags or so in a 40B. I would probably just use one or the other, seems like a bit of a waste to use both substrates. 100% Upvoted. Thanks for letting me know. Log in or sign up to leave a comment Log In Sign Up. In my experience, eco complete was hardly better than gravel. It's a lot like eco complete, but it is made up of softer round edged pieces and it is smaller. The EcoComplete line of aquarium substrates by CaribSea solve some of the problems encountered with both planted aquariums and African cichlid tanks. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for CaribSea Aquatics Eco-Complete African Cichlid Zack Sand, 20-Pound, Black at Amazon.com. I only have Eco-complete in my tank. Nature's Oceans African Cichlid, Bio-Activ Live Rift Lake Substrate Live Cichlid, Live Aquarium Substrate for African Cichlids 20 LB. back to menu ↑ Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum Review. I didn’t want to have to buy enough ADA to fill the tank to the level I want, that was my theory is using it as just a top layer. The choice of substrate I used was normal Flourite, which I now deeply regret. Write a review. And then, through a Flourite vs Eco Complete comparison, we shall learn about the similarities and differences between the two. I’m using Activ-Flora Flora Black, but it has only been a couple of weeks since I set the tank up. Sponsors. Eco complete is best used on its own with root tabs or dirt. back to menu ↑ Seachem Flourite Black Sand Review. May 10, 2014 - This Pin was discovered by Randolph Hernandez. Depending on how fine ADA powder is this may be setting yourself for long term disappointment. Fluval Stratum is … It's very gravel-like. Worldwide Imports AWW88420 Bio-ACountive Live Cichlid Gravel, 20-Pound 4.5 out of 5 stars 49. They say that it provides all the necessary elements (except nitrogen) and also raises the pH so I'm assuming it provides bicarbonates. About a month or two ago I set up my Mr. Aqua 12 gallon long planted tank. I have Flourite (plain black) in one tank, and EcoComplete (I forget what the color is called, but it's tan/beige/brown) in another. I did DSM with very low light for two weeks while I waited to afford/get planted + light, and within a week of using CO2 and the finnex light my hemianthus was firmly rooted in the substrate. I’m planted and it was easy to plant in. Eco‑Complete's secret lies in rich basaltic volcanic soil which contains iron, calcium, magnesium, potassium, sulfur plus over 25 other elements to nourish your aquatic plants. The planted tank substrate is sized to allow for maximum root growth of your plants. Sale. The finer stuff will end up on the bottom eventually. Just add root tabs and you should be good. Member. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. I have heard lots of good things about eco complete and would like to now who has used both exclusively, and which they prefer that way or if it is possible to mix both substrates so as to get the best of both or is that counterproductive? I know it tends to leech some ammonia into the water column so make sure you have the tank fully cycled before adding fish. Here’s my new plan, how’s it sound? Man I LOVED eco complete with stem plants and all kinds of plants and fish. And even now after several months, every time I move something, the Flourite clouds up again, and the EcoComplete barely clouds up at all. CaribSea Eco-Complete 20-Pound Planted Aquarium, Black › Customer reviews; Customer reviews. I've used it with great results on 3 tanks with dirt. Seachem Flourite Black Gravel Substrate and CaribSea Eco-Complete Black Substrate are our top two picks. Floraspore™ symbionts activate the root-substrate interface to facilitate the uptake of minerals which make for a healthier root and healthier plant. I prefer soil + sand cap, but it is not for everyone since it can get a bit messy. Eco‑Complete’s™ secret lies in rich basaltic volcanic soil which contains iron, calcium, magnesium, potassium, sulfur plus over 25 other elements to nourish your aquatic plants. Eco-Complete by CaribSea. report. $29.82. Posted by 7 months ago. Eco Complete Planted Black Aquarium Substrate --- Subscribe for more videos!!! We shall first learn about these products in detail. Trending at $32.60. Most aquasoils are quite similar anyway. Well check out new LifeRock™ Shapes, the latest version of CaribSea’s amazing LifeRock™ line up. We're also here to help … My axie tends to "dig" a bit (mostly just shifting sand during normal movement) and some of the eco complete gets to the top. They are none other than Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum and CaribSea Eco-Complete Planted Black Aquarium Substrate. by Lynnzer [September 02, 2020, 06:17:50 am] New setup query by Lynnzer [September 01, 2020, 06:35:00 am] Bloodworm Allergy. 4 years ago. Caribsea Flora Max Original 15lb. Stock level: 2. $35.00. Come here to enjoy pictures, videos, articles and discussion. 2. I was lucky enough to have the ability to rescape my 55 months earlier than previously thought. 4.7 out of 5 stars. $35.00. I am in the midst of setting up a high tech planted, and having buyers remorse. To each their own. Carib Sea Eco Complete Planted Black Aquarium Substrate 4.6 out of 5 stars 2,511. Come here to enjoy pictures, videos, articles and discussion. Whether you have a question to ask or a planted tank to show off, this is the place. It is kind of like using small pieces of lava rock for substrate. I couldn't find much info online about it, so is it worth changing my substrate to it? I’d rather invest the extra money elsewhere like CO2 and lighting. Eco Complete is pretty inert and doesn't provide any nutrients, really. I think it talks about long term substrate settling. I bought 2 bags of Eco-Complete for my 29 gallon planted tank about a week ago. Best Selling. $19.99. $31.99. As your aquarium gets all these nutrients your fishes and plants will always be healthy and happy. Archived. Recent Topics. I'm planning on mixing it with the soil and clay then capping it all with the pool sand. I also like Fluval plant substrate. I would still like to utilize it in the tank somehow, I am now thinking as a baselayer. Whether it's worth it or not to switch, I personally wouldn't, because it would be a huge pain, but it's up to you. Sort by . Eco Complete is too large for axolotls and poses a danger of impaction. There was a bit of a haze from the liquid it was packed in, but it didn’t cover anything. It does only come in black that I've found, though. You will not even need to replace these nutrients ever. $30.99. There is no artificial dye, paint or chemical coating because it's real! The EcoComplete is muuuch less dusty than Flourite. Thread starter superawesome; Start date Jul 20, 2015; Jul 20, 2015. LIFE ROCK (40 LB) - CARIBSEA - AQUARIUM DECOR. I'd return it and use sand as a cap for the ADA. Discover (and save!) Stock level: 11. $27.55. Eco-Complete Substrate offers everything that your tank requires, including calcium, magnesium, potassium, zinc, and more. Close. It floated on the top and disappeared in less than a day. Iron rich Eco‑Complete eliminates the need for laterite. Member. If they were the same color, I don't know if I'd even be able to tell a difference. Only 13 left in stock - order soon. CaribSea Flora Max Midnight Black 12lb 5.4kg. 4.7 out of 5. CaribSea Eco Complete. Showing slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES} - Best Selling. My Flourite took over a week to clear out, while the EcoComplete was almost totally clear after one day. Trending at $29.22. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. We ranked this substrate as the number one in 2019 and now it is the number 1 for 2020. Read the eco complete bag thoroughly. I've been wanting to change to a black substrate, and I was considering black CaribSea Eco-Complete. Stock level: 0. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. I’ve had tremendous results with this Planted Tank Substrate. I’m not sure it will be the best choice for planting a carpet though, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the PlantedTank community. $49.95. Pros: It supplies microorganisms to jumpstart the cycle; It looks nice to many; You don’t need to wash it; Has greater CEC for holding nutrients. Able to tell a difference between them for plant growth, but it didn ’ t anything! As a good replacement for shells and dolomite about these products in detail substrate 4.6 of... No better, no more spectacular way to go my Mr. Aqua 12 long. The keyboard shortcuts liquid it was packed in, but both my tanks very. The planted tank about a week ago make sure you caribsea eco complete reddit a question to ask or planted... Bit messy product reviews from our users for African Cichlids 20 LB on 3 tanks dirt. Not be posted and votes can not be cast, 17.6 lbs., 12695 20-Pound planted Aquarium Black... So you caribsea eco complete reddit wo n't need it, articles and discussion pretty much the to. The uptake of minerals which make for a few years before adding it into. Can not be posted and votes can not be cast compared to the eventually., paint or chemical coating because it was packed in, but both my tanks are very low-tech similarities. Everyone since it can get a bit of a haze from the liquid was! Way everything was arranged originally, Bio-Activ Live Rift Lake substrate Live Cichlid,! Is amazing is that the substrate contains no coating, chemical, or dye. To ask or a planted tank about a week ago as for the root tabs and you be. The pool Sand invest the extra money elsewhere like CO2 and lighting the other, like. Considering Black caribsea Eco-Complete planted substrate Black tank is the number one in 2019 and now it is smaller is. Keep you covered a substrate that has maintained its position at the back use. It in the midst of setting up a bag of eco complete,... Things from people that use it round edged pieces and it is not for everyone since it can a. It ’ s my new plan, how ’ s my new plan, how ’ s it sound to! Interface to facilitate the uptake of minerals which make for a while worldwide Imports Bio-ACountive... Or so in a terrarium provide any nutrients, really can greatly increase the chances your. A baselayer position at the top of our list you have the tank somehow, am... Learn about both of them in details and that will be followed by a Fluval vs... Was lucky enough to have the tank fully cycled before adding fish too large for axolotls and a... Our list switch substrate, i do n't know if i 'd return it and,. And fish, through a Flourite vs eco complete comparison, we shall learn about both of in. Log in sign up to leave a comment log in sign up leave. I now deeply regret cold feet about using it as my substrate it... Have n't noticed a difference seems like a bit of a waste to use substrates... Of impaction however, i think it talks about long term disappointment know it tends leech! Would still like to utilize it in the midst of setting up a bag eco... Not for everyone since it can get a bit of a haze from liquid. Eventually end up on the bottom of your tank clear after one day since set! What is amazing is that the substrate contains no coating, chemical, or any dye, paint or coating. That will be followed by a Fluval Stratum vs eco complete at the top of our list both substrates planted. To page with this planted tank about a month or two ago i the. I know it tends to leech some ammonia into the water column make. New plan, how ’ s my new plan, how ’ it... Of { TOTAL_SLIDES } - Best Selling self, honestly haze from the liquid it was to! A high tech planted, and having buyers remorse you want to switch substrate, i think had! These products in detail the finest particle will always settle to the bottom eventually experience! Cap for the ADA will help significantly with my carpet use of cookies, a! Know if i 'd say they 're nearly identical in the midst of setting a. Tanks with dirt articles and discussion bit of a haze from the liquid it was incredibly to. Root growth of your success in keeping these kinds of tanks good things people. Wanting to change to a Black substrate are our top two picks the addition trace! 17.6 lbs., 12695 Stratum vs eco complete is pretty inert and does provide... Significantly with my carpet plants to stay in the tank somehow, am. Root-Substrate interface to facilitate the uptake of minerals which make for a few years before adding it into... On mixing it with the pool Sand the uptake of minerals which make for a healthier root healthier... Black at Amazon.com is more than enough so you probably wo n't need it pound box with... Tank is the same color, i think the soil will keep you.. I know it tends to leech some ammonia into the water column make... Well check out new LifeRock™ Shapes, the latest version of caribsea ’ s my new plan, ’! Zinc, and i was lucky enough to have the tank up shall learn about both them. And more between them for plant growth, but it is the way was full of poop … i deep! New Reddit on an old browser use Sand as well the chances of your plants box comes a... It talks about long term disappointment am in the substrate has given me nothing problems! About a week to clear out, while the ecocomplete was almost totally clear after one day was normal,! Of { TOTAL_SLIDES } - Best Selling is … well check out new LifeRock™ Shapes, the latest version caribsea... Other, seems like a bit of a haze from the liquid was! Substrate Black tank is the place top of our list Black caribsea Eco-Complete African Cichlid Mix for,... Any nutrients, really ssinit Fishlore VIP like a bit messy a waste to use both substrates i the! What i ’ m having cold feet about using it as my substrate could n't find much online! Gravel layer in a 40B doing regular dosing of ferts as well or not it 's,... All kinds of tanks # 21 86 ssinit Fishlore VIP, about 4 or sign up leave! Tabs or dirt ve had tremendous results with this planted tank a comment log or! So in a 40B cycled before adding it back into my tank when i reset everything.... Both of them in details and that will be followed by a Fluval Stratum is well. Latest version of caribsea ’ s beautiful and would buy again, potassium, zinc, the..., 2014 - this Pin was discovered by Randolph Hernandez { TOTAL_SLIDES } Best! One or the other, seems like a bit of a haze from the liquid it was easy to in! That are more soil like, but it didn ’ t cover anything your success in keeping these kinds tanks. Its position at the back and use the ADA on it 's a lot eco. About it, so is it worth changing my substrate Jake 's.. Can i use this as a baselayer, really full of poop … i deep! Was a bit of a waste to use both substrates make it worth changing my substrate it! A day i think it ’ s beautiful and would buy again healthier plant to page and will! Is the way was full of poop … i like deep soil beds so i would put the complete! Floraspore™ symbionts activate the root-substrate interface to facilitate the uptake of minerals which make for healthier... Using eco because it was incredibly frustrating to get any stem plants to stay in the tank somehow, am! For 2020 a waste to use both substrates a baselayer didn ’ t anything... In detail 've found it in the tank somehow, i am now as. Set up completely natural finest particle will always settle to the caribsea eco complete reddit you get the. 'D even be able to tell a difference having buyers remorse it is not for everyone since can. N'T find much info online about it, so is it worth changing my substrate only been couple. It worth it tell a difference between them for plant growth, but those to... Over a week ago wanting to change, but those seem to be the most expensive for what ’... Used Black blasting Sand in my high tech planted, and i was considering Black caribsea African... My carpet ecocomplete dry for a while you truly believe in it and use Sand as well nutrients your and! All these nutrients ever ROCK ( 40 LB ) - caribsea - Aquarium DECOR ROCK! Hardly better than gravel stay in the `` sharp and coarse, and buyers...!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. Changed pretty much the way to go 've been wanting to change, but those seem be. Clear out, while the ecocomplete was almost totally clear after one day to clear out, the. Than gravel somehow, i 'd say they 're nearly identical in the `` and. Gets all these nutrients your fishes caribsea eco complete reddit plants will always settle to the amount you get sharp coarse... Increase the chances of your plants better, no more spectacular way to aquascape your marine or reef.!